Legacy: Unaligned Monks United

L5R CCG Rules board, 15 July 2011

A topic from AEG's L5R CCG Rules forum, copied for Oracle of the Void from a copy of the forum saved in October 2015, so pages it didn't save are missing. Players' names are left out; the rules officials are named. Rulings are as they stood on these dates; later rulings, the rulebooks and the Rules Archive may differ.

A player, 15 July 2011

I'm playing with a Brotherhood of Shinsei stronghold (eg Brotherhood of Shinsei) and control five Unaligned Monks (eg three Akifumi and two Gyosho). These five monks have the printed boldface "Unaligned", and by the rules this means: Unaligned

The term “unaligned” refers to a Personality, player, or Stronghold without a Clan alignment. Unaligned Personalities do not have the same Clan alignment as an unaligned player or Stronghold, nor do they have a different Clan alignment from anything. “Unaligned” is not a keyword.

Can I play United, targeting my five Unaligned Monks? Since per the rules they are personalities without a clan alignment, they cannot share Clan Alignments...

Battle/Open: Target five of your non-Shadowlands Personalities, no two of whom share a Clan alignment: Give each of them +4F. Negate their movement home from other players' actions until the turn ends.

Brook Cunningham (rules official), 15 July 2011

I'm playing with a Brotherhood of Shinsei stronghold (eg Brotherhood of Shinsei) and control five Unaligned Monks (eg three Akifumi and two Gyosho). These five monks have the printed boldface "Unaligned", and by the rules this means: Unaligned

The term “unaligned” refers to a Personality, player, or Stronghold without a Clan alignment. Unaligned Personalities do not have the same Clan alignment as an unaligned player or Stronghold, nor do they have a different Clan alignment from anything. “Unaligned” is not a keyword.

Can I play United, targeting my five Unaligned Monks? Since per the rules they are personalities without a clan alignment, they cannot share Clan Alignments...

Battle/Open: Target five of your non-Shadowlands Personalities, no two of whom share a Clan alignment: Give each of them +4F. Negate their movement home from other players' actions until the turn ends.

No, you may not play United targeting 5 Unaligned Monks in Legacy format.

If you are playing Legacy format, "Monk" is a Clan/Faction alignment. So, those Personalities DO have one, even though they also have the "Unaligned" keyword. The first Cardinal Rule is that card text takes precedence over Rules. In this case, the text "Monk" takes precedence over the definition of "Unaligned" that you cited.