In Time of War and rehonoring

In Time of War is in play. I have gained 5 honor this turn already. My opponent dishonors one of my personalities. This personality then generates an honor gain. Would the personality rehonor?

Yes, because of the Blind Cards rule: http://rules.l5r.com/Effects#Blind_cards_rule

In reference to: http://www.alderac.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=59&t=74329&start=0

From the rules wiki:

Resolving timing conflicts

(snippage)

A. Apply any ongoing or continuous effects, such as "can not" wording, that negate or otherwise modify the occurrence that defines the trigger. For example, "can not move home" negation happens at this point prior to a unit moving home, so that no other triggered effects, traits or actions can respond to the unit's movement. The active player decides the order in which more than one of these effects apply.

---> In Time Of War applies here

(more snippage) C. Apply any triggered rulebook effects that are not part of actions, such as rehonoring Personalities instead of Honor gain. The active player decides the order in which more than one of these effects apply.

So, according to this, In Time of War ongoing "can not" negation effect should apply before the rehonoring of personalities.

Is there anything wrong in this reasoning?

You're applying rules for timing conflicts, but this isn't a timing conflict (i.e., two things trying to occur at the same time). The question isn't, "When is the Honor gain squelched?" but "Is there an Honor gain at all?" The blind cards rule says, "Yes."

In Time of War creates a negation effect that negates all honor gains that would rise a player's family honor above a value. Source Tentatively I'd classify this effect as an ongoing negation effect (but it could possibly be continuous). Correct me if I'm wrong.

It has also been stated that reactions "before a player gains honor" always come before this negation effect. Source. I'd also say that, since honor gains and losses are instantaneous effects, I think it makes no sense applying it "after a player gains honor", but you're entitled to disagree.

My search-fu of cards with triggers to honor gains shows that all cards I found that modify an honor gain do it "before" the gain. If "In Time of War" modifies them with other timing, it could possibly be unprecedented. Feel free to bring forth other cases.

Assuming a player's family honor has risen to his value when the turn started plus 5, that player is about to gain X honor When will the negation effect of In Time of War be applied? Before he gains the honor? Retroactively, after the honor has been gained? At the very moment both players pass consecutively to the trigger for reactions "before a player gains honor" and before anything else happens? At the end of the turn? Some other timing I haven't thought of?

Thank you in advance

We're talking about this in the Rules Junta. Stay tuned.

any update on this topic viewtopic.php?f=59&t=74329

Sorry for creating a new topic, i can't seem to reply on any topic here in the rules question page.

Nothing to report. We won't hold out on you, honest, we'll tell you when something happens.

The forum is deliberately set up so that only Rules Team can reply. This way, we don't have people jumping in offering unofficial opinions, which causes confusion. We manually merge relevant threads.