No Hiding place

L5R CCG Rules board, 5 February 2006

A topic from AEG's L5R CCG Rules forum, copied for Oracle of the Void from the Wayback Machine (its copy), so posts it didn't save are missing. Players' names are left out; the rules officials are named. Rulings are as they stood on these dates; later rulings, the rulebooks and the Rules Archive may differ.

A player, 5 February 2006

OK first thing, I know you have already answer to this before. But I do not understand the logic.

Your answer was:

Zamalash wrote:

(C)an I use No Hiding Place to target my opponent's personalities at other battles?

"Even if it is at the Defender's home" (Card text). No.

It is not mentionned:

Must or may target an opponent card at home,

It is mentioned:

No Hiding Place:

Reaction: Before choosing the target for an uncombined Ranged Attack from a card you control in the attacking army: The Ranged Attack may target a card even if it is at the Defender's home. The Ranged Attack has –1 strength

"Even if it is" it does not mean: The ranged attack may target at the defender home. The word EVEN open more possibilities like ranging somebody who's defending in another battle. If it is not working, well the card is clearly unintuitive and there should be a rewording on the card.

By the way No Hiding Place should means No Hiding place, not even in your provinces

P.S: Thanks Zen for making it clear that with the wording on this card we can target a card in other provinces

(Mod edit: Formatting. -ZF)

Zen Faulkes (rules official), 5 February 2006

OK first thing, I know you have already answer to this before. But I do not understand the logic.

Your answer was:

It is not mentionned:

Must or may target an opponent card at home,

It is mentioned:

No Hiding Place:

"Even if it is" it does not mean: The ranged attack may target at the defender home. The word EVEN open more possibilities like ranging somebody who's defending in another battle. If it is not working, well the card is clearly unintuitive and there should be a rewording on the card.

By the way No Hiding Place should means No Hiding place, not even in your provinces

P.S: Thanks Zen for making it clear that with the wording on this card we can target a card in other provinces

(Mod edit: Formatting. -ZF)

Ranged Attack normally target cards in the same battlefield. No Hiding Place allows only one extra location the target can be: the Defender's home. No other battles allowed.