Lonely Dojo

L5R CCG Rules board, 19 November 2014 to 20 November 2014

A topic from AEG's L5R CCG Rules forum, copied for Oracle of the Void from a copy of the forum saved in October 2015, so pages it didn't save are missing. Players' names are left out; the rules officials are named. Rulings are as they stood on these dates; later rulings, the rulebooks and the Rules Archive may differ.

A player, 19 November 2014

Lonely Dojo:

After you Equip a Follower paying 1 or more Gold, give this Holding +1GP (this turn).

Lonely Dojo says nothing about the gold cost of the follower attached, only the gold paid during the Equip action. If I Equip a 0 Gold Cost follower and pay 1 gold do I still get the +1 GP?

Brook Cunningham (rules official), 20 November 2014

Lonely Dojo:

Lonely Dojo says nothing about the gold cost of the follower attached, only the gold paid during the Equip action. If I Equip a 0 Gold Cost follower and pay 1 gold do I still get the +1 GP?

No, you don't. If you produce the Gold, but don't use it, you didn't "pay" it.

A player, 20 November 2014

Reply to viewtopic.php?f=59&t=110940

I do not understand the response to the question.

If you produce the Gold, but don't use it, you didn't "pay" it.

I am pretty sure I clearly stated that I was "paying" 1 gold for the EQUIP action.

If I Equip a 0 Gold Cost follower and pay 1 gold do I still get the +1 GP?

I will step through the exact process:

1. Announce the Equip Action 2. Bow Abundant Farmlands to Produce 1 Gold and add it to the gold Pool 3. Choose to Pay 1 gold for the equip action, removing 1 gold from the gold pool 4. Resolve the remaining effects of the Equip Action, attaching the 0 gold cost follower Shield Wall.

5. I "Equiped" a follower "paying 1 or more gold" so Lonely Dojo gets +1 GP.

If the intent was to exclude 0 gold cost followers, then it should have been worded "After you Equip a Follower with 1 or more gold cost, gain +1 GP".

Alex Jones (rules official), 20 November 2014

Reply to viewtopic.php?f=59&t=110940

I do not understand the response to the question.

I am pretty sure I clearly stated that I was "paying" 1 gold for the EQUIP action.

I will step through the exact process:

1. Announce the Equip Action 2. Bow Abundant Farmlands to Produce 1 Gold and add it to the gold Pool 3. Choose to Pay 1 gold for the equip action, removing 1 gold from the gold pool 4. Resolve the remaining effects of the Equip Action, attaching the 0 gold cost follower Shield Wall.

5. I "Equiped" a follower "paying 1 or more gold" so Lonely Dojo gets +1 GP.

If the intent was to exclude 0 gold cost followers, then it should have been worded "After you Equip a Follower with 1 or more gold cost, gain +1 GP".

According to p36 of the Comprehensive Rules, the Equip ability is: Repeatable Open, (*): Attach an attachment card, with Gold Cost equal to the amount you paid, from your hand to your target Personality.

If you pay 1g when Equipping, you cannot choose a 0g Follower as the attachment.