Several question

L5R CCG Rules board, 7 December 2009

A topic from AEG's L5R CCG Rules forum, copied for Oracle of the Void from a copy of the forum saved in October 2015, so pages it didn't save are missing. Players' names are left out; the rules officials are named. Rulings are as they stood on these dates; later rulings, the rulebooks and the Rules Archive may differ.

A player, 7 December 2009

I'm hoping to go to Kotei this year and wanted to get some stuff straightened out first.

1. I was told any action on a ninja personality counts as a ninja action is this true? If so is the same true for tacticians? 2. Can I use Touch of Ice on my turn without bowing the shugenja? 3. Can Falling Leaf Strike be us like Unwavering Assault as far as enemy prescence goes? 4. Does Unpredictable Strategy count as moving? 5. If a card like Shunran lose force bonuses, does he also lose his +2F for attacking? If so then does this also negate the guidance? 6. If I Retribution can I use my personalities battle abilities again? 7. Can I choose to dishonor a dishonored personality? 8. Does the Scorpion guidance negate the honor gain from Well Defended Border? 9. Do I still have to be the attacker for Ring of Earth's reaction or can I just be allied to get it into play?

Dan Jacobson (rules official), 7 December 2009

I'm hoping to go to Kotei this year and wanted to get some stuff straightened out first.

1. I was told any action on a ninja personality counts as a ninja action is this true? If so is the same true for tacticians? 2. Can I use Touch of Ice on my turn without bowing the shugenja? 3. Can Falling Leaf Strike be us like Unwavering Assault as far as enemy prescence goes? 4. Does Unpredictable Strategy count as moving? 5. If a card like Shunran lose force bonuses, does he also lose his +2F for attacking? If so then does this also negate the guidance? 6. If I Retribution can I use my personalities battle abilities again? 7. Can I choose to dishonor a dishonored personality? 8. Does the Scorpion guidance negate the honor gain from Well Defended Border? 9. Do I still have to be the attacker for Ring of Earth's reaction or can I just be allied to get it into play?

1. For the first part, yes, any action printed on a personality with the Ninja keyword is a Ninja action. Yes, every action on a personality with the Tactician Keyword is a Tactician action. However, it is NOT a Tactical action (which is restricted by the Rulebook to once per turn) unless otherwise printed as such.

2. No, the "If it is not your turn" is a restriction to playing the action

3. No, the targeting of the enemy personality on Falling Leaf Strike is required targeting, and thus must be met to be able to use the action.

4. Switching is the same as moving. If one movement is negated, the other one is as well. (Hamstrung, Travelling Papers, The Height of Courage, etc)

5. That depends on the effect that negated the force bonuses.

6. All abilities are once per turn unless otherwise stated. Retribution does not create a new turn, it only creates a new Phase.

7. That depends on the effects. If you have a choice in the matter (say, Bayushi Kurumi Experienced's action), then yes, you may choose to dishonor a dishonored personality, and the dishonor effect will simply fail.

8. If you mean "Bayushi's Guidance", then yes. Well-Defended's honor gain is during the Dynasty Phase, which is reduced by one via Bayushi's Guidance.

9. You must be the Attacker or the Defender to play Ring of Earth via its text. Allies may not play Ring of Earth for being on the winning side of a battle.

Please make sure to specify the cards you want questions answered about, with actual card names. Generalities make it difficult for both us, the Rules Junta to answer and other players to find answers when they search the Rules Forum.

Please use the Search Function before you ask questions, as they may have been asked and answered already.

Good luck at the Koteis!

Zen Faulkes (rules official), 7 December 2009

I was told any action on a ninja personality counts as a ninja action is this true?

http://rules.l5r.com/CE_Card_features#Abilities: "An ability also has any keywords that are on its card. Example: An ability on a Ninja card is a Ninja ability."

If so is the same true for tacticians?

"Tactician" is not "Tactical."

Can I use Touch of Ice on my turn without bowing the shugenja?

No. viewtopic.php?f=59&t=63095

Please use the search function -- it will answer many questions faster then we can.

Can Falling Leaf Strike be us like Unwavering Assault as far as enemy prescence goes?

It would be useful if you were a bit more specific. In what way?

Does Unpredictable Strategy count as moving?

http://rules.l5r.com/CE_Glossary_S#Switch: "This may involve movement if units are switched between two locations." Generally, yes.

If a card like Shunran lose force bonuses, does he also lose his +2F for attacking?

Yes. It's a bonus; see http://rules.l5r.com/CE_Card_features#B ... _penalties

If so then does this also negate the guidance?

I don't understand the question.

If I Retribution can I use my personalities battle abilities again?

Generally not, as abilities by default are once per turn: see http://rules.l5r.com/CE_Abilities_and_a ... esignators.

Can I choose to dishonor a dishonored personality?

Depends on the card text; this FAQ entry should help: http://rules.l5r.com/CE_FAQ#Is_an_actio ... _happen.3F

Does the Scorpion guidance negate the honor gain from Well Defended Border?

I don't understand the question.

Do I still have to be the attacker for Ring of Earth's reaction or can I just be allied to get it into play?

You must be the attacker. http://rules.l5r.com/CE_Battles#C._Resolution_Segment: "The winning army’s leader (the Attacker or Defender) is the winner of the battle."